Forgotten Island Tier List Hub

Forgotten Island on Roblox is a Simulation/Tycoon loop, not a PvP ladder, so this Tier List Hub ranks spend order instead of duel win rates. You collect Memories across Nakali Island, dodge Aswang, bank Fragments, grow Jeepney storage, and roll bracelet charms. The lists below are a community snapshot for September 2026. They are inferred from badge text, the visible shop loop, and how runs actually fail. They are not a datamined table of Fragment costs, gold prices, or drop percentages.

If a number is not on a badge or in the live shop UI, it does not belong on this wiki. That is why you will not find a spreadsheet of upgrade gold here. Qualitative ranks still help: they tell you what to buy first when the island is loud and your inventory is already sweating.

How these ranks work

S means the pickup or purchase that saves a run. A still pays for itself if you make it home. B is early filler that teaches the island. C is cosmetics-adjacent and can wait. We do not invent Fragment tables. Upgrade order, stated only as a rank: storage first, then Memory yield, then charm luck, cosmetics last. That order matches the loop. A Mythic Memory is worthless if the Jeepney is already full. Extra yield is worthless if you keep dying in ash. Luck is worthless if you have nowhere to put the drop.

Use the child pages when you are actually spending:

• Memory tiers for what to chase and what to leave on the sand
• Charm tiers for the bracelet, including Duwende Crown
• Jeepney tiers for slots versus Home Base cosmetics

Memory ranks at a glance

Open the full memory tier list when you choose a route.

• S — Mythic Memories. Huge risk, huge payoff. The badge “Oof that’s gotta sting” confirms Mythic exists and that losing one hurts. Do not carry Mythic without spare Jeepney slots.
• A — High-yield Memories that survive a trip home. These thicken later laps without asking you to live in the danger zone.
• B — First Memory and beach filler. You need them to start the album and learn the beach-to-treeline line. They are not your late spend.
• C — Cosmetics-adjacent Memories. They look good in the album. They do not bank Fragments.

Rarity in this experience runs at least from common through Mythic. We do not pretend to have a complete public ladder beyond what badges and the loop show.

Jeepney and charm ranks at a glance

The Jeepney upgrade tiers exist because storage is the bottleneck.

• S — Extra storage slots. Every extra slot is another Memory that can live through an Aswang scare.
• A — Run-start Home Base upgrades. Prep that makes the next lap start cleaner. Still behind raw slots.

Bracelet charms are the luck layer. See charm tiers.

• S — Duwende Crown. The rare named charm worth chasing once storage is not embarrassing.
• A — Any charm that helps you bank more. If it does not help the walk home, it is not A.

Charm Luck and VIP (wolf pack) are convenience passes. They are not required to finish the loop, and they do not outrank storage. Buy them if you like the pack energy or want a smoother roll. Do not buy them instead of slots.

How to use this hub on a live server

Read the three child lists before you spend. Then play one lap with a plan: beach filler first, bank, buy a slot if you can, then push treeline. If you wipe, you still have the album progress you already stored. Pair this hub with how to get Memories, Jeepney upgrades, and how to dodge Aswang. For roster context, the Players Hub explains who is hunting you. For what changed, see the Updates Hub.

Treat this hub as a spending filter: if a purchase does not protect a Memory on the walk home, it is not S, no matter how loud the shop UI is.